The European Parliament’s Industry, Research and Energy (ITRE) Committee has failed to adopt an opinion on the post-2030 review of the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS), leaving its proposed contribution to the wider legislative process without an agreed position.
The outcome on 19 November prompted criticism from European energy-intensive industries, which are seeking changes to carbon allowance allocation, industrial emissions benchmarks and the treatment of exports under the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM).
The European Steel Association (EUROFER) and other industry representatives argue that the proposed framework must reflect the practical costs of industrial decarbonisation, including the investment required to replace existing production equipment and secure alternative energy supplies.
The failure to adopt an ITRE opinion does not mean that the European Parliament has rejected the ETS review. The legislative process continues, and the committee’s unresolved position does not alter the obligations already applying to industrial installations under the existing emissions trading framework.
The ETS places a limit on greenhouse gas emissions from covered activities and requires operators to surrender allowances corresponding to their verified emissions. The available supply of allowances declines over time, creating a financial incentive for companies to reduce emissions.
Industrial businesses covered by the scheme include steelmakers, chemical producers, cement manufacturers and operators of other energy-intensive installations. Their carbon costs depend on actual emissions, the price of allowances and the allocation arrangements applicable to their operations.
For many of these businesses, substantial emissions reductions require changes to core production processes rather than adjustments to individual pieces of equipment. An industrial furnace, chemical reactor or primary steelmaking installation may form part of a production system developed around particular energy sources and raw materials.
Replacing that infrastructure can involve major capital investment, changes to supporting utilities and additional requirements for power or other industrial feedstocks. The equipment must also be integrated into an operating factory while maintaining the quality and quantity of products supplied to customers.
The industry’s first request concerns free allowance allocation. European manufacturers want this protection against carbon leakage to remain available without additional investment conditions attached to its receipt.
Carbon leakage describes the risk that production moves to jurisdictions with less demanding emissions costs rather than that emissions are reduced through industrial technology changes. Free allocation has been one of the mechanisms used to address differences between the carbon costs faced by EU producers and overseas competitors.
Industry representatives argue that making allocation dependent on particular investment commitments could increase financial pressure before the necessary low-carbon energy, infrastructure and production technologies are commercially available at a suitable scale.
The second request concerns the cross-sectoral correction factor, which can reduce free allocation where calculated entitlement exceeds the allowances available under the relevant cap. The industry coalition wants the revised framework to avoid a steep reduction triggered by this mechanism.
According to the coalition, Commission estimates indicate that free allocation could be reduced by as much as 70% by 2040 through the correction factor. That figure is presented as a potential outcome identified by industry, not a confirmed reduction already enacted.
Industrial benchmarks form the third area of concern. The benchmarks are used to help calculate free allocations based on the emissions performance expected from defined industrial activities.
Where the benchmark assumes performance that cannot be achieved through the production routes or technologies available to a particular installation, the resulting allowance allocation may differ substantially from the site’s actual operating requirements.
EUROFER and its partners want future benchmarks to reflect the different technical pathways through which industries can reduce emissions, including variations in raw materials, energy supply and the availability of supporting infrastructure across member states.
In steel production, for example, a change from conventional blast furnace operations to alternative processes can involve new equipment, suitable iron feedstocks and substantial electricity or hydrogen requirements. An installation cannot necessarily make that transition within the same timeframe as another plant operating under different industrial conditions.
The fourth request concerns CBAM, which applies carbon-related requirements to specified imported products. Industry representatives want the mechanism to provide effective protection against carbon leakage as free allowances are phased down.
Export markets are a particular concern. European producers selling products outside the EU may compete with manufacturers that do not face equivalent domestic carbon costs. A border measure applying to imports into Europe does not automatically resolve that competitive difference for exports.
The coalition is consequently calling for CBAM arrangements that address export competition alongside imports, with the reduction in free allocation aligned to a realistic transition pathway.
Its fifth request is for greater reinvestment of ETS revenues in industrial decarbonisation. Manufacturers argue that allowance revenues should help finance the equipment, infrastructure and energy systems needed to reduce emissions from covered production activities.
Such investment may include process electrification, alternative fuels, energy infrastructure and replacement manufacturing technologies. The technical route varies by sector, while the economics depend on capital expenditure, operating costs and the availability of suitable industrial energy supplies.
Affordable electricity is especially important where production is expected to shift towards electrically powered processes. New equipment may reduce direct emissions at the factory while increasing dependence on reliable power supplies, network capacity and competitive electricity prices.
The coalition’s proposals reflect the position of the industries it represents. They do not establish that carbon pricing is inherently incompatible with industrial emissions reductions, nor that the ETS review must adopt every requested change to achieve its environmental objectives.
The ITRE result leaves those competing considerations unresolved within the committee’s contribution to the parliamentary process. Further negotiations will determine which industrial provisions, if any, are incorporated into the European Parliament’s eventual position.
Existing ETS obligations remain in force while the post-2030 framework is developed. Manufacturers considering long-term investments must therefore continue assessing current carbon costs alongside possible changes to allowance allocation, energy infrastructure and the economics of future production technologies.



